Techno-Economic Assessment, Process Synthesis, and Design of Malonic Acid Production

Yumei Zhao^*
*Correspondence: Yumei Zhao, Department of Biomass Science and Engineering, Sichuan University, Chengdu, China, Email:

Introduction

Malonic acid, also known as propanedioic acid, is a dicarboxylic acid with two carboxyl groups (-COOH) attached to a three-carbon chain. It is an important intermediate in the chemical industry, used in the synthesis of various products, including pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals, and polymers. Due to its versatile chemical structure, malonic acid is involved in the synthesis of a wide range of organic compounds, such as barbiturates, vitamin B1, and various herbicides. The demand for malonic acid has been steadily increasing, driven by its application in fine chemicals, materials science, and the production of bio-based and sustainable chemicals. In this context, the synthesis and production of malonic acid have become a topic of significant research and development, with a focus on optimizing production processes to make them more efficient, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly. This article explores the techno-economic assessment, process synthesis, and design of malonic acid production, emphasizing recent advancements and the challenges involved in scaling up production. The traditional method for producing malonic acid involves the cyanoacetic acid process, in which cyanide and acetic acid react to form cyanoacetic acid, which is subsequently hydrolyzed to produce malonic acid. While this process is effective, it has significant limitations, including the use of toxic and hazardous reagents (such as cyanide) and environmental concerns related to waste generation. These issues have prompted researchers to explore alternative, greener methods for malonic acid production.

Description

One promising approach involves the bio-based production of malonic acid, using renewable feedstocks such as sugars or biomass-derived chemicals. This method typically employs microbial fermentation or enzymatic processes to produce malonic acid, offering the potential for a more sustainable and environmentally friendly process. The synthesis of malonic acid via microbial fermentation generally involves the use of genetically engineered microorganisms, such as Escherichia coli or Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which can metabolize carbon sources like glucose, glycerol, or other sugars to produce malonic acid. The process is based on the principle of biosynthesis, where microorganisms convert simple carbon substrates into value-added products through biochemical pathways. The advantage of this method lies in its use of renewable raw materials, the potential for lower energy consumption, and the reduction of hazardous byproducts. To improve the efficiency of bio-based malonic acid production, research has focused on optimizing microbial strains, fermentation conditions, and metabolic pathways. The genetic engineering of microorganisms allows for the enhancement of malonic acid yield by overexpressing key enzymes involved in the malonate biosynthesis pathway, while also minimizing the production of undesired byproducts. Advances in synthetic biology, metabolic engineering, and systems biology have enabled the development of highly efficient strains capable of producing malonic acid at higher titers and productivity. Additionally, fermentation process parameters such as temperature, pH, oxygen supply, and nutrient composition are carefully optimized to maximize malonic acid production [1].

In terms of process synthesis and design, the production of malonic acid can be analyzed using various methodologies, including Process Flow Diagrams (PFDs), material and energy balance analysis, and process simulation tools. A process flow diagram outlines the key steps involved in the production of malonic acid, from the preparation of raw materials to the final product recovery. For example, in a bio-based process, the PFD would include the stages of fermentation, downstream processing (e.g., separation and purification), and product formulation. The Techno-Economic Assessment (TEA) of malonic acid production is an essential part of process design, as it helps evaluate the economic feasibility and profitability of the process. TEA typically involves analyzing the costs associated with raw materials, utilities, labor, equipment, and other operational expenses. Capital costs for setting up a production facility, as well as ongoing operational costs, must be taken into account to determine the overall cost per unit of malonic acid produced. By comparing different process routes, such as conventional chemical processes versus bio-based processes, the most cost-effective and sustainable production method can be identified. A key element of the TEA is the estimation of the production cost, which includes both fixed and variable costs. Fixed costs typically consist of capital investment, including the cost of building the production facility, purchasing equipment, and installation. Variable costs, on the other hand, are directly related to production, such as raw material costs, energy consumption, waste disposal, and labor. In a bio-based malonic acid production process, raw materials such as glucose, glycerol, or other carbon sources can account for a significant portion of the variable costs. In contrast, the capital costs associated with fermentation equipment, bioreactors, and downstream processing steps must also be carefully considered [2].

One challenge in the bio-based production of malonic acid is the potential for high raw material costs, which can significantly affect the overall cost of production. However, if renewable feedstocks such as agricultural residues or waste streams can be utilized as carbon sources, the cost of raw materials can be reduced, making the bio-based process more competitive. Additionally, improving fermentation efficiency through metabolic engineering and optimizing the fermentation process can lead to higher yields and lower overall costs. Energy consumption is another important factor in the techno-economic assessment of malonic acid production. Both conventional chemical and bio-based production processes require significant energy inputs, particularly for heating, cooling, and maintaining optimal conditions for fermentation. The use of energy-efficient equipment, such as heat exchangers, membrane filtration systems, and energy recovery systems, can help reduce the overall energy consumption of the production process. Additionally, integrating renewable energy sources, such as solar or wind power, into the production facility can improve the sustainability of the process and reduce reliance on non-renewable energy sources [3].

The recovery and purification of malonic acid from the fermentation broth or chemical reaction mixture is a crucial step in the production process. Several separation techniques can be employed, including filtration, distillation, solvent extraction, and crystallization, depending on the specific process. The choice of recovery method is influenced by factors such as the purity required for the final product, the concentration of malonic acid in the mixture, and the presence of impurities. The efficiency of these separation processes can have a significant impact on the overall cost of malonic acid production, as the purification steps often account for a substantial portion of the operational expenses. In addition to cost considerations, the environmental impact of malonic acid production must also be evaluated. Sustainable production methods, such as bio-based processes, offer the potential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and environmental pollution associated with traditional chemical processes. By using renewable raw materials and reducing the reliance on toxic reagents, bio-based production methods can contribute to the transition toward a more sustainable and circular economy. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) can be used to evaluate the environmental impact of different production routes, considering factors such as carbon footprint, water usage, and waste generation [4,5].

Conclusion

To further enhance the competitiveness of bio-based malonic acid production, research efforts have focused on improving process integration and optimization. By using process simulation tools, different process configurations and operating conditions can be modeled and optimized to minimize costs and maximize efficiency. Process integration involves combining different unit operations in a way that maximizes the use of energy and raw materials while minimizing waste generation. Techniques such as heat integration, material recycling, and the use of byproducts can help reduce the environmental and economic impact of malonic acid production. In conclusion, the production of malonic acid has significant industrial relevance, particularly in the fields of pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals, and materials science. While traditional chemical processes have been widely used, the development of bio-based production methods offers the potential for more sustainable and cost-effective alternatives. The techno-economic assessment of malonic acid production plays a critical role in evaluating the feasibility and profitability of different production routes, taking into account factors such as raw material costs, energy consumption, capital investment, and environmental impact. By optimizing microbial fermentation processes, improving process integration, and leveraging renewable feedstocks, bio-based malonic acid production can become a competitive and sustainable alternative to traditional chemical methods. As research in this field continues to advance, it is expected that new innovations and improvements will further enhance the efficiency, scalability, and cost-effectiveness of malonic acid production, contributing to its wider application in the global market.

Acknowledgment

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1. Witkowski, Andrzej, Jennifer Thweatt and Stuart Smith. "Mammalian ACSF3 protein is a malonyl-CoA synthetase that supplies the chain extender units for mitochondrial fatty acid synthesis." J Biol Chem 286 (2011): 33729-33736.

   Google Scholar, Crossref, Indexed at

2. Bouillaud, Frederic. "Inhibition of succinate dehydrogenase by pesticides (SDHIs) and energy metabolism." Int J Mol Sci 24 (2023): 4045.

   Google Scholar, Crossref, Indexed at

3. Song, Chan Woo, Je Woong Kim, In Jin Cho and Sang Yup Lee. "Metabolic engineering of Escherichia coli for the production of 3-hydroxypropionic acid and malonic acid through β-alanine route." ACS Synth Biol 5 (2016): 1256-1263.

   Google Scholar, Crossref, Indexed at

4. Gu, Shuying, Zhen Zhao, Yonghong Yao and Jingen Li, et al. "Designing and constructing a novel artificial pathway for malonic acid production biologically." Front bioeng biotechnol 9 (2022): 820507.

   Google Scholar, Crossref, Indexed at

5. Ding, Qiuyan, Zhengkun Hou, Xueli Geng and Guiyu Gao, et al. "Investigation of sustainable reactive distillation process to produce malonic acid from dimethyl malonate." Sep Purif Technol 315 (2023): 123730.

   Google Scholar, Crossref, Indexed at